Unit 1, Lesson 7: David Says Yes to the Rule of Law!
Featured Text for This Unit
By David Shannon
This lesson is a great reinforcement for the big idea of this unit, “Democracy Calls for Equal Justice Under the Law”, and a great summary about the importance of the rule of law. Using cartooning, students draw David, and have him “make a statement” regarding his understanding of the Rule of Law.
Materials & Resources Needed
- Handout #1 — Cartooning template with margin and lines for the book (PDF)
- Handout #2 — Brainstorm page:
- Cartoon sample ideas (Large PDF: 1.5 MB / Three Pages)
- Sample symbols page (PDF)
- Pencils, black fine sharpies or ink pens, marking pens, crayons, and/or oil pastels
Visual and Performing Arts Content Standards for California Public Schools/Visual Art, Communication and Expression Through Original Works of Art
- 2.7: Communicate values, opinions, or personal insights through an original work of art.
Essential Question / Issue in this Lesson
- In what ways does the Rule of Law apply to impartiality of the courts?
- Students will understand the beginning concepts of cartooning.
- Students will summarize their understanding of the Rule of Law as evidenced through the written comments of their cartoon character.
The objectives above will be assessed through final product of cartoon entry to class book.
Quality Criteria for Assessment
Student follows cartooning elements: design, color, and good use of space to portray character in an effective manner.
David’s comments are reflective of an understanding of the meaning of the rule of law following his “experience” in court! Uses vocabulary indicative of understanding.
Learning Activities (55–60 minutes)
Hook (2 minutes)
David has learned a lot about the Rule of Law, given his experience of being charged with theft! We are going to become cartoon artists, and decide what David would have to say about the rule of law following his experience! Show the cover (provided, or use your own). David says Yes to the Rule of Law.
Review (5–10 minutes)
First we will review what David learned about the Rule of Law (use brainstorm sheet, Handout 2: Teacher Edition PDF or Student Edition PDF)
Students brainstorm: What does the Rule of Law mean? What we want students to review are the following important concepts:
- The Constitution has the laws that must be followed.
- People are innocent until proven guilty.
- The jury and the judge must learn about details that show proof of the guilt.
- Impartiality means it has to be fair to everyone and that decisions must be based on the law.
- The judge and the jury must be impartial.
- The jury must believe the defendant (David) is guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt”
Following the brainstorm: Students will decide what they want David to say about the rule of law on the cartoon page they will make.
Examples of what we are looking for — and hopeful students will create their own!
- “I’m innocent until you can prove I am guilty!”
- “If you aren’t absolutely sure I’m guilty, beyond a reasonable doubt, then I am innocent!”
- “The jury cannot decide that I am guilty just because I’ve been in trouble before!”
- “You have to be impartial, and make a decision in a fair way, based on the law!”
- “Are you looking at evidence and the stories on both sides?”
Cartooning (30–40 minutes)
Introduction: Students need to practice creating David before they begin their actual page with the dialogue.
Using pencil, they can begin to practice by sketching David’s head (the author has David with quite a round face). This sample sketch could be with David facing forward to get started.
David’s body (just below a skinny neck) is an oval – the legs and arms are almost “sticks”, his facial features are very distinct, so students usually find much success as they play with making David. (See beginning practice sheet)
Students may want to make David with different facial expressions, turning sideways, in the court, classroom, with some symbols that represent the law, with the jury…let their imaginations run wild! They will ask for the David books, and this gives ideas as well…Do Not Let Them Trace!
Encourage them to plan their design using the full page, and to make David a good size so that he shows up well and is the center of attention! NOTE: One of the graphics pages gives symbols of the court (PDF) – the Scales of Justice should be explained to students, even though on the vocabulary page– the scales of justice have been used to symbolize the balance between truth and fairness sought after in the justice system.
After plenty of practice with pencils and “scratch paper”, you can give them the Handout 1 page that has a margin drawn on the left. This margin is to be kept clear for the book “binding”, and lines at the bottom for the written comment they want from David (Handout 1 PDF provided). You may want to use drawing or construction paper fir their final copy, rather than paper that will tear too easily.
- Students sketch out their cartoon David (and scene if applicable) page with pencil.
- Outline the entire drawing with black ink when completed.
- Write the dialogue with pencil first.
- Go over the dialogue with black ink when completed.
- Finish with color: markers and crayons give lots of options.
*Idea: This could be set up as a “cartoon center” for students to get lots of practice and time for creativity.
Samples of Student Cartooning Work:
Closure (5 minutes)
Put all student entries into a class book and share the book with the whole group. It is fun to take a photo or scan each page and then present as a power point (great for a parent-night too!). Reinforce the Big Idea from the unit: Democracy calls for equal justice under the law. The book will be out for all to look through and enjoy as a summary of their learning.
Students could create their own book on the Rule of Law — make an ending to what happened following the trial, or a completely different “case”.
- No, David! by David Shannon
- Visual and Performing Arts Content Standards for California Public Schools
- Cartooning Basics, Barnhart, firstname.lastname@example.org